Dear Nick Hogan,
Thanks largely to the efforts of a few bloggers, you are now back home following a stint in Forest Bank jail in Pendlebury. A huge amount of credit for this must go to Anna Raccoon and Old Holborn, who rallied to your cause and did some seriously speedy fundraising in order to secure your release through delivering £8,664.50 to your prison’s doorstep. No doubt you are flattered and delighted that complete strangers dipped into their pockets for you and your family due to their enormous sense of grievance at what happened to you. Even so, my mood is far from jubilant this morning.
The backstory to your prison sentence is a sad tale. You were jailed for non-payment of a fine that was originally imposed for a ‘mass smoke-in’ on the day the smoking ban came into force in 2007 in your pub, the ‘Swan and Barristers’ in Bolton, which you no longer own. You were fined again when council inspectors walked into your present pub and discovered a group of customers smoking, even though you weren’t on the premises. The fines bankrupted you, and you went to court intending to argue that you could not afford the £500 a month payments demanded by the council towards their £10,000 bill for prosecuting you (although you had managed to pay off £1,600). In response to your non-payment, the court gave you a 6-month jail sentence instead. This left your wife to manage the pub and left you unable to earn the money which would ensure your release. Your poor wife was not able to speak to you after you were sentenced and was merely informed of where you would be jailed. I can imagine that the whole experience was very frightening and disorienting for her. In short, you objected to the smoking ban and hosted a small demonstration against it on the day the ban came into force, and you paid a heavy price.
As Anna Raccoon said, “Nick was jailed as an example to us all, that when the State barks ‘jump’ you only question ‘how high’. He didn’t. He said ‘Why’? …The fact that so many of you responded is a powerful message from the voting public that politicians would be well advised to heed. The Blogosphere will not be controlled by politicians, bound up in regulations, throttled by impenetrable legislation. It is not a single target that a ‘D’ notice can be fired at. We are not beholden to advertisers. We are the authentic, unfiltered, voice of your electorate.” I’m sure you would agree that your release from jail has shown how quickly a small group of supporters can be mobilised to help someone, which is encouraging in itself. However, I still have a heavy heart as I write this letter because I fear that even though the blogosphere has won the battle, we have not and will not win the war.
The relentless attacks on our civil liberties over the past 13 years will not be forgotten quickly by many bloggers, but it has gone largely unnoticed by many voters. To most people, DNA databases are nothing but an abstract headline, 42-day detention was supported by many, ’stop and search’ is unlikely to affect them, wheelie bin computer chips are little more than an irritation and ‘benefit snoopers’ from the local council will never need to call at their house. You don’t have to tell me about ‘first they came for the communists etc etc’ because I get it, but bloggers should never forget that we are all here because we care – many other people do not. I am always amazed and even amused by the way that mainstream journalists talk about events in Westminster politics as if anyone other than a handful of voters actually give a crap. The vast, vast majority of people in this country simply don’t have the time or energy or inclination to care about what the government does, and tragically that extends to civil liberties too. Some of them even support draconian measures like ID cards because the government have such a powerful voice and can deceive and lie to their heart’s content about why they are doing things and what effect their plans will have.
I would love to think that your release from jail would be a turning point regarding the influence of the blogosphere on the world outside and on policymakers, but I know deep down that it isn’t. Anna Raccoon felt that the help you received sent a “powerful message from the voting public that politicians would be well advised to heed”, but they won’t. Politics has concentrated power into the hands of literally 10-15 people at the very top of the political tree, regardless of which party is in charge, and they have no reason to fear the electorate or bloggers as we have so little genuine power over them. Yes, we can protest and yes, we can kick up an almighty fuss, but I wonder how much more we have to offer besides being a right royal pain in the arse. I can only hope that a Conservative Party, which still contains the likes of David Davis and a few other staunch defenders of liberty, will start to roll back the tide of destruction that Labour have overseen on our liberties and freedom. Sadly, I fear that ‘hope’ is all we can do.
Yours sincerely,
A.Tory
RECENT COMMENTS